When you build on the same two-square-mile island for forty years, you learn a few things about wood, water, and the families who live there. I would like to tell you what.

I started Vitarelli Construction in 1984. The island was different then in some ways and exactly the same in others. The streets were narrower. The houses were smaller. But the families who lived in them cared about the same things ours do now: a house that holds up, a builder who picks up the phone, and a kitchen big enough to feed the people you love.

What you learn first is that salt air is patient. It does not announce itself. It works on a house slowly, finding every joint that was not perfectly sealed, every fastener that was not the right alloy, every piece of trim that was a quarter-inch out of plumb. Forty years on the island means I have seen the consequences of small shortcuts taken decades ago. I do not take them.

What forty years teaches you about salt air

You learn to spec stainless where most builders spec galvanized. You learn that even the right paint will not save the wrong substrate. You learn that the windows facing the bay need a different approach than the windows facing the alley, and that your client will not understand why until you explain it twice.

You learn that the cheapest material is rarely the cheapest material, and that the most expensive one is rarely worth the markup. The middle path is the one that ages the way the family wants it to. You learn which lumber yards still mill the way they used to, and which ones have stopped caring. You learn which subcontractors will come back on a Saturday to fix something small, and which ones won't. You make a list, and you stop calling the rest.

A bayfront home built by Vitarelli in 2023
A bayfront new build completed in 2023. The roof line was the hardest part.

What forty years teaches you about families

The houses on the island have grown larger. The families have not. They have just gotten more deliberate about what each room does, and how the spaces between rooms work. The best brief I have ever heard came from a grandmother on Coral Avenue: "I want the kitchen to be where the people are, and the dining room to be where the people end up."

That is what we build for. The rooms that hold a family together, and the rooms a family ends up in when the gathering finally settles down. The rest of the design follows from those two ideas. The hallways, the sightlines, the way the back door opens onto the patio. Every decision points back to the same question: where do the people want to be, and how do we get them there easily.

"The marketing is the work. Most of our projects come from neighbors of the last project. That is not an accident."

I did not set out to build a business that runs on referrals. I set out to build houses I would be proud to walk past. The referrals came because the houses held up. The neighbors saw, and the neighbors called. Forty years later, we are still answering the phone the same way.

If you are reading this, you are probably thinking about a project. A new build, or a renovation, or a home that needs care year-round while you are not on the island. Whichever it is, the first step is the same: call us. The phone rings, one of us picks it up.

The work begins with a conversation. The conversation begins with you.

Dennis Vitarelli

Founder · Vitarelli Construction

Dennis founded Vitarelli Construction in 1984. He still walks every job site and still answers the phone.

Have a project in mind?

Start a conversation